jump to navigation

Organizational culture of Wal-Mart January 30, 2007

Posted by Lady in Organizational Culture, Retail.
trackback

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/01/26/business/26walmart.html

 

Basically this was an article that stated that Wal-Mart just recently settled a
U.S. federal lawsuit about overtime paid to its’ employees. Wal-Mart agreed to pay $33.5 million to its’ employees for overtime they had worked without pay. The U.S. Labor Department was accusing Wal-Mart of labor violations which led to this lawsuit. In addition, forty other states had filed lawsuits against Wal-Mart in regards to overtime violations.

 

Before the lawsuit was settled, Wal-Mart had recently “denied any liability for the accusations in the lawsuit”. But ironically, an associate director in the department’s Fair Labor Standard’s Division, Steven Mandel, commended Wal-Mart for this recent settlement of this overtime issue. He said that Wal-Mart asked for their support because they needed assistance with these “complicated efforts”.

 

Moreover, Wal-Mart officials are proud of their accomplishment of correcting their errors in overtime calculations. Sue Oliver, senior vice president of Wal-Mart’s HR division, said, “We want our associates to know that the situation has been fixed, that overtime calculations now are being done correctly, and that we’ve added safeguards to our payroll processes to make sure these type of errors don’t happen again”. She also feels that Wal-Mart has acted in good faith because they decided to compensate their employees for five years in back wages although the Labor Department only requires two years of compensation. She also stated, “We are commited to our associates…we work very hard to make sure associates are compensated correctly.” Now that this lawsuit is finally settled, close to 87,000 employees will receive compensation for the overtime that they had previously worked.

 

I wanted to mention this article to question Wal-Mart’s organizational culture. What does it say about their organizational culture–is it good or bad? Sue Oliver’s statements make it seem as though they are committed to taking care of their employees and in that sense, I guess that would speak highly of their culture. However, another question could also be–should this issue have even occurred in the first place? What type of organizational design does Wal-Mart have where employees are working hard and not being fully compensated for their efforts? Might these errors in their organizational structure affect the relationships between the employees and management? I believe that it would. Might the lack of proper compensation lead to management’s loss of trust from employees? Might employees start to question the ehtics of Walmart? I believe that it is possible. Maybe Wal-Mart only agreed to pay out the compensation because they got caught. Wal-Mart is already known for being a “bully” because they have so much power. However, I believe that these errors in overtime compensation displays a weakness in their organizational culture and could lead to increased employee turnover rates.

 

But on the other hand, one might think that this settlement makes Wal-Mart’s culture look good because they are taking a step towards improvement, looking to make their organizational culture stronger by compensating their employees. Although this is a possibility, I am leaning more towards my former explanation. What does everyone else think?

About these ads

Comments»

1. Charley S - January 30, 2007

Wal Mart is notorious for treating employees, or “associates”, poorly. My bet is that Wal Mart knew full well that they were doing something wrong. Of course now that someone took the time to look into the problem they are putting on a good public face, but from what it sounds like this is a, “Uh Oh, we’re busted,” kind of reaction. I’m also pretty sure that Wal Mart won’t really care about having higher employee turnover because it already has high turnover, and they spend minimal amounts of money training these people, who are a dime a dozen for Wal Mart.

2. wilson7 - January 31, 2007

It is mind boggling to me how something like this happens inside a major corporation like Wal-Mart. How do you not pay your employees for their overtime? On the other hand, how are you an employee and do not realize that your check is a couple of hundred dollars short of what it is supposed to be? If you know you worked overtime and it is not in your check why would you not say something? There is no way that Wal-Mart did not know that they were not paying them for overtime. They keep track of all hours worked and what peoples paychecks should look like. They were caught trying to get over on their employees and are trying to compensate for it by paying out five years instead of two. I am not buying it.

3. silviamocanu07 - January 31, 2007

Wal Mart is very well-known for the poor treatment to its employees. Long-hours and unfair compensation are usually the norm. I read a book called “Nickel and Dimed” by Barbara Ehrenreich, in which she does research about the unskilled work conditions in the US. The writer actually obtains a job at Wal Mart and her experience there seems to be the worst from any of the other jobs that she undertook for research purposes, such as maid and waitress.
Ehrenreich particularly highlighted the poor, long hours, as well as the constant supervision for the lower ranking employees, to ensure that they were never slacking off or taking unauthorized breaks.
I think Wal Mart in general abuses the amount of power that they hold in order to impose poor working conditions on their employees.

Jason - August 19, 2012

Since when is foolowing up on productivity for unauthorized breaks and not slacking off a bad thing? Have you ever worked seriously for a business? poor? long hours? You mean the hours that you like to shop at your convenience? the hours you said you could work when you applied for the job?

4. Professor Jordi - February 4, 2007

Great post! I like how you laid out questions for people to answer.

Wal-Mart, I read somewhere, is the single entity after the federal government, that is involved in the most litigations as a defendant. In short, they get sued a lot. Some of that is due to size. We may wonder how much is due to specific qualities or WM.

You bring up culture. If there were specific practices or policies that directed managers to encourage employees to restock after clocking out, is that a policy or a cultural norm?

And Terrance points out, how can something like this go on in such a large company? Is government enforcement that weak? Is that part of the national culture? I think so. Many Americans like to complain about how intrusive the government is. Maybe, but the trade-off is that something so clearly wrong, not paying employees even the LOW wages that is part of their explicit labor contract, becomes possible.

I don’t think it was an accident or an honest mistake. If you want to see more on this, look for WM and promoting women or hiring illegal workers through contractors.

5. alex - December 1, 2009

Walmart got caught doing what it wasn’t suppose too. Someone got wise and told on them. They are bullys and because they are so big, not many people will go against them. It takes something like the law to actually get them to do what is right.
Just to get an idea of how much they are trying to keep everything their own way. The first 20 minutes of their orientation for new hires is anti – union. They want to make sure that no union gets inside to help the employees. If that happened, then Walmart couldn’t do all that it is doing wrong now…

6. Carlos Herrera Jr. - July 21, 2010

Can you provide the name and addresses for all the higher- ups past the individual store managers?

7. David T. - January 17, 2011

I just found out that after cutting my part time hours to 8-12 hours a week, the also decided not to pay me for the work I did. I checked my time sheets and i worked a total of 54.14 hours between 1-1-11 and 1-14-11(6 hours were holiday hours for 1-1-11). I looked at my paystub and it only shows 40 hours worked and 6 hours holiday (46.14 with all the little minutes). The only reason its not less is I work in TLE and with the number of tecs we have its not possable to have us work any less and still have coverage. If anyone can point me to the right person to talk to I would be appreciated. The management at my store (2092 Ogdensburg NY) is in the dark about a lot of things, and I dont know how the got where they are.

8. Jason - August 19, 2012

First in reference to your comment on orientation and Union talk, Walmart simply covers the ability of an associate to come to any level management within the company at anytime and that our open door culture does not make individual representation necessary for an associate to voice their opinions. Next with this boob who says he did not get paid correctly. The sheer fact that he references time sheets, which we do not use, indicates that he was unable to keep track of his time electronically which every associate has access to. On a side note, if he was part time and received 6 hours of Holiday pay, his average daily hours over the last 3 months were 6 hours per day, which he was paid. I have one word for all of your comments: FACTS and Credibility or lack there of.

9. davidsonrrfh.unblog.fr - June 16, 2013

I enjoy what you guys are usually up too. This sort of clever work and exposure!
Keep up the wonderful works guys I’ve added you guys to our blogroll.

10. portable clothing racks - July 5, 2013

These corporations can provide further info not listed in the physicians place of work these
as further organizations that manufacture and sell incontinence solutions,facts about bed-wetting help teams,and
many others. If you like to clip your trousers and skirts, appear for
multifunctional hangers that contain this selection.
Further space in a good deal of laundry rooms can be like creating serious estate in New York Metropolis.

11. 소라넷새로운주소 - August 19, 2013

간신이 세치혀를 놀리지만 시민들은 바보가 아니고
저 간신이 바보같네

12. Jody - September 1, 2013

I find it interesting how so many informed people complain and talk bad about a company they have either never worked for or know nothing about except what is said by other people. If you are going to talk about a company, make sure you have your facts correct. Sure it is not always peaches and cream, but for some it is a job…a means to pay the bills. I don’t know of ANY business that does not have its share of problems or bad management or anything like that. You will have your bad managers, you will have your crappy jobs, you will have mistakes being made to one degree or another…but if you do not open your mouth…you not see things get fixed. So yeah….let’s beat up on a company that employs millions of people. Let’s bad mouth a company who does what it can for its employees when possible. Let’s complain about a company who chooses to fix things themselves rather than rely on a union that wont do crap for the employees. Way to go. Get informed before you start talking trash about a place you know nothing about.

13. charlotte seo company - March 11, 2014

Everything is very open with a precise description of the issues.
It was truly informative. Your site is extremely helpful.
Many thanks for sharing!

14. work from home free - March 24, 2014

Pretty element of content. I simply stumbled upon your blog and in accession capital to say that I get
actually enjoyed account your blog posts. Anyway I will be subscribing for your feeds or even I
achievement you get admission to constantly fast.

15. cheap auto insurance san diego - March 26, 2014

There are lots of good auto insurance agencies in the state, and you cannot
select or evaluate all of the quotes. You can drop the premium of your auto insurance
policy if you drop something like medical. Whiplash is the
most common result of an automobile accident and this is especially so in a rear end
collision.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

%d bloggers like this: